I was just on #therpsite and it inspired me a little idea for what I think would be a cool editorial/blogitorial feature: Discussion Reviews.
Two people pick up the same game, read it, then get into a chatroom or messageboard (or email or whatever) and have a friendly discussion about the game. What they liked, disliked, thought was cool, what you'd do with it etc.
You then format/edit the discussion into a readable format and post it as a review for a RPG/supplement or whatever.
So, what do you think? Cool idea? No?
Anybody want to do a discussion review with me (or, with anybody really :P)?
Anybody want to donate a .pdf or book for a discussion type review?